A British music schooling group studies that use of recorders are declining within the classroom. We surprise: Why have been they there to start out with? And why is “Scorching Cross Buns” such a banger?
AYESHA RASCOE, HOST:
You understand that great-sounding instrument youngsters be taught in elementary college, the recorder?
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
RASCOE: In case you someway managed to flee attending one in every of these concert events, the recorder is a woodwind music instrument. It is bought a thumb gap and 7 finger holes. And when it is performed by a gaggle of youngsters, it usually appears like, properly, you inform me.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
RASCOE: Based on a brand new report, although, from the Related Board of Royal Colleges of Music in the UK, the variety of youngsters studying the recorder has dropped.
ESSEL LINTON: There’s undoubtedly been a shift in our curriculum.
RASCOE: That is Essel Linton, a music trainer in Annandale, Virginia. She says using the recorder has declined in American lecture rooms, too, out of necessity.
LINTON: Throughout COVID time, we have been restricted in utilizing the wind devices.
RASCOE: Is sensible – different devices needed to substitute. Linton, for instance, turned to the ukulele. She says different lecturers used digital know-how on computer systems to show younger virtuosos.
LINTON: My colleague and I introduced recorder again with our third graders. We began it again, like, two years in the past. And the scholars like it, however there’s undoubtedly different alternatives. So I might perceive that there is perhaps a discover of a decline.
RASCOE: That is perhaps music to your ears, however Linton says in terms of studying to play an instrument, there’s actually no comparability. The recorder reigns supreme.
LINTON: You understand, it is reasonably priced. You should purchase a reasonably respectable plastic recorder instrument for lower than $10. You understand, it is moveable. The youngsters choose up on it fairly shortly.
RASCOE: And it means youngsters can shortly grasp that outdated favourite, “Scorching Cross Buns.”
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
RASCOE: (Singing) One a penny, two a penny, sizzling cross buns.
LINTON: It requires three pitches, going from one word to the opposite subsequent to one another, so I really feel like that is simply the primary tune that everyone is aware of.
RASCOE: Enjoyable reality, it additionally shares a melody with “Three Blind Mice.” As a music trainer, Linton additionally has to take heed to quite a lot of this. So does she prefer it?
LINTON: Sure, I really like the recorder, particularly once they play properly. So I imply, I’d say the very first time we educate recorder to 3rd graders, I sort of need to mentally put together myself.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
RASCOE: Most youngsters be taught to play the recorder as a bridge to different wind devices like clarinet or trumpet. However the recorder is not any kid’s instrument. Lots of the nice composers wrote music for recorder, like Johann Sebastian Bach.
(SOUNDBITE OF AMSTERDAM BAROQUE ORCHESTRA PERFORMANCE OF BACH’S “CANTATA NO. 182”)
RASCOE: Essel Linton performed in a recorder ensemble when she was rising up in South Korea. She says it is a disgrace that the majority college students do not proceed with recorder after the third and fourth grades. In the event that they or anybody follow and be taught to make use of their breath correctly, they might develop as much as play the recorder in addition to Essel Linton.
LINTON: (Enjoying recorder).
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts might differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.